Unsupported Browser

We've detected an older browser version that will not give you the best experience while using The Atlas. Please consider revisitng this site after downloading one of the alternatives below.

Survey of City Employees Gives Insight on Job Satisfaction Amid Great Resignation

The City of Novi

Novi, MI

The City of Novi, Michigan, surveyed its employees to understand how staff members feel about their jobs. The City wanted to gauge employee satisfaction and identify areas of improvement to maintain retention, which is more important than ever as the Great Resignation continues to cause workforce shortages.

Topics Covered

Workforce & Education

Cost

Initial: 15.5 Thousand USD

Funding

General Fund/Existing Public Funds

Project Status

Operational since 2021

Gov Champion

City Manager

Problem Addressed

The City of Novi wanted to know how its employees feel about their jobs.

Novi was interested in an internal employee assessment before The Great Resignation. But conducting an employee survey in 2021 was good timing. Many people have reevaluated their relationship to work as a result of the pandemic. And the national staffing shortage has empowered employees to seek jobs with more flexibility, better benefits, and better pay. 

Local governments, in particular, are having trouble recruiting younger people to take the place of the retiring workforce. As a result, there are around 700,000 fewer public sector workers today than pre-Covid. Local government has to adjust to these shifting perspectives to create a work environment that attracts and retains valuable staff members in a competitive market. To do so, however, it's vital that government leaders understand how employees feel about the workplace. 

Solutions Used

Novi surveyed its workforce to find out how it could improve job satisfaction and retain valuable staff members. 

The City used the National Employee Survey (The NES) by Polco to gather insights on staff opinions toward their work. The NES investigates employee job satisfaction and key characteristics of their work environment. Local governments and organizations all over the country conduct The NES, so anyone who completes the assessment can compare their results to the national average and see how they measure up. 

“We wanted to do The NES to see where employees stand, and to get a baseline for our culture and hopefully try to start building on that,” said Victor Cardenas, Novi's Assistant City Manager. 

All City of Novi employees were mailed a postcard with a link inviting them to take the anonymous survey online. Out of 516 invitations, 179 Novi employees completed the survey, a 35% response rate. The data were weighted to give a more accurate portrait of the entire staff. 

The NCS results revealed that, for the most part, The City of Novi was either on par or exceeded the national average. For instance, around 80% of employees said they are satisfied with their jobs, 95% said they have good friends at work, and 94% said the City provided a safe and secure work environment for people of all backgrounds. All three ratings are higher than the national average.

The results also showed that 96% of employees planned on working at the City for more than a year, surpassing the national benchmark. That positive statistic is meaningful since many people are currently changing careers and leaving their jobs. 

The City also scored well above the national average for employee development. Novi is generous with their further education opportunities. 

“It’s something we hang our hat on in terms of how we support further education, so that was a good affirmation of our efforts,” Cardenas said. 

But the survey also uncovered a few areas where they could focus on improvement. Only 54% reported positive ratings for human resource services, and 65% said they feel positive about benefits overall, both lower than the national average. The survey results prompted officials to host focus groups to learn more about what could be done to improve services. 

“We want to learn more—tell us why,” Cardenas said.  “We are starting to dig deeper and inviting more feedback.”

In one of these sessions, a police officer suggested officials reach out to other high performers on The NES to learn what they were doing to cultivate high employee job satisfaction.

Outcomes

1

Novi received survey results on job satisfaction and areas of improvement from 179 employees, which directly supported decision-making to enact changes and enhance employee retention

2

The majority of Novi's workforce plans on working at the city for more than a year, surpassing the national benchmark

3

The City identified the human resources department as an area of improvement and hosted focus groups to get more context and hear potential solutions from employees themselves

4

Novi bolstered employee retention by increasing its 457 contributions based on how many years employees have worked with the City

5

Novi officials plan to conduct The NES every two years to gauge the City's progress in creating a healthy work environment for staff

Lessons Learned

1

The City reached out to all departments to brainstorm potential solutions and address low-rated areas of job satisfaction, giving employees a much-needed opportunity to get involved.

Something Unique

Governments that survey to learn more about their communities or internal operations are typically higher-performing municipalities overall.

Who Should Consider

Any local government that wants to create a thriving workplace and ensure that valuable employees stick around for years to come.

Government Project Team

  • Victor Cardenas, Assistant City Manager
  • Peter E. Auger, City Manager

Last Updated

Jul 25th, 2022
More Local Gov Case Studies from The Atlas Database
The Atlas case study database features examples of city projects – including both earth-moving projects and installed technologies – from around the world. You will not find proposed projects, or links to research studies and planning documents. There are 500+ member submitted case studies to browse - see related case studies to this one below:
Browse All Case Studies